Asceai様 has graced us with his list of top 100 eroges.
If you don’t know who he is…. well you don’t need to know actually. He’s just another ero jiji hacker you find everywhere. Just that I argue with him (obviously friendly arguements) about eroges a lot and he’s also doing somthing for the AsuKimi project.
I have a few minor issues about his list as we do have pretty different tastes, a fact we both agree about. Though there is no doubt everything from his top 25 are all very epic eroges.
The videos are in ascending order so start with part 1 first. And yes he agreed to let me post about it =D.
Without further ado, let’s get on with it.
Accany's VN Dump 
I’ve understood how much you love Asceai by reading the post (´・ω・｀)b
てへ～
/me blushes.
Not really no. XD.
Very nice, thanks for those videos! I wasn’t bored one moment. I’ve played only a few of those games but I find it quite hard to believe that all of those 57 games that are on top are better than Fate/Stay Night.. ^_^
FSN isn’t exactly a very good eroge. It’s just that it’s overhyped. There are a lot of eroges out there actually better than it.
…Cartagra, Narcissu, Umineko, and higurashi needs to be higher, and while I do love G-senjou (obviously, I’m on the translation team after all), I think that the side stories drag it down too much for it to be #1
I also think that Fate stay night is over hyped, but even so, it deserves a higher place, should be higher than Ef, at least.
But seriously, that’s A LOT of games. I’ve only played a little over 100 games myself (counting those short doujins)…Maybe I’ll get to that kind of place one of these days…
Ef latter tale to me was a lot better than FSN… at least to me.
And that’s not exactly a lot. I think I musta broken the 150 barrier already but I don’t remember 1/2 of what I played before I started this blog (I formatted my computer >_>)
CORRECTION EF IS THE BOMB @_@ and it deserved just to be on the best other than FSN being to much hyped which however you look at it does no good. <_< then again its a doujin group and with that much fame that rival's ZUN is already a feat lol
爆弾でたあああああああああああああああああああああああああああああああ！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！
I do like Ef, but when I played through the first tale I didn’t really feel anything, then I watched the anime and REALLY fell in love. Similar things happened to the latter tale, but I did like the latter tale a lot more than the first tale. And the anime failed to include Mizuki’s back story…(cry). It’s kind of like, when I was playing the latter tale and I saw what happened to Yuko, I was like “Ohh, ouch”. And when I watched the 6th episode of a tale of melodies I was /(ㄒoㄒ)/~~， absolutely chocked. So when I think of Ef, I remember how it could have been better than the anime and that made me rate it lower.
Hi, I really hope I’m not asking too much but would you happen to have a list of those eroge in text file or something?
I’ kinda new to this eroge thing so could you recommend some that would have english translation? (I dont speak/read japanese)
Any help is appreciated
TIA!
Meh it’s not my list, it’s asceai’s. I think he has it on a list since he picks out stuff pretty easily. Ask him over at #denpa on synirc. He’ll answer you I think.
Umm, List, I didn’t as him but sat there and made this out of my own need:
100. Gore Screaming Show
98. Kao no Nai Tsuki
97. Yoake mae (making)
96. Koisuru Otome (making)
95. Dies Irae
94. Katakoi no Tsuki
93. Cartagra
92. Katahane
91. Magic a Ride
90. Eve – burst error
89. Noel
88. Shinjyu no Yakata
87. Paradise Lost
86. Serina (M)
85. Bye
84. Koi no Bashi
83. Higurashi
82. Sakura Strasse
81. KIller queen
80. Haru no Ashioto
79. One
78. Dear my Friend
77. Kano Aozora ni
76. Shizuku
75. Saya no Uta
74. Narcissu *m)
73. Amatsukaze
72. Kimi ga Nozomu Eien
71. Shikkoku no Sharnoth (nice)
70. Ashita Deatta Shoujo
69. Rui wa Tomo wo Yobu
68. Kusari hime
67. Little Busters (M)
66. Muv Luv Alternative
65. Flutter of Birds
64. A profile
63. Phantom – intergration
62. Ashita no Kimi Autame
61. Umineko no Naku
60. Gun Katana
59. Mindead Blood
58. Fate?stay night
57. Sekai de Ichiban na Koi
56. Tenshi no Inai
55. Kusari
54. Gunjyou no sora
53. Forest
52. Kagerou Touryuuki
51. Shinigami no Seppun
50. StarTrain
49. Kikajikake no eve
48. Ikusa megami zero
47. Ayakashi
46. Sengoku Rance
45. Tsukihime
44. Gin iro
43. Mugen Kairou
42. Extravaganza
41. Toki hako time capsule
40. Kizuato *L*
39. Doko he iku no, ano hi
38. Ever 17
37. 11eyes – tsumi
36. Tsuyokiss
35. Baldr Force
34. Ef
33. Scarlett
32. Air
31. 3days Michite yuku
30. Natsu no tomoshibi
29. Kono Yo no Hate de Koi wo
28. Sekien no Inganock
27. Sakura Musubi
26. Yumemi Shi
25. Helo, world
24. Aster
23. Swan song
22. Parfait Chocolat second
21. Haruka ni Aogi
20. Yukiuta
19. Suigetsu
18. Eien no Aselia
17. Konata Yori
16. Kazoku Keikaku
15. Clannad
14. Shoshite ashita no sekai yori
13. Tapestry you will meet yourself
12. Kira kira
11. Symphonic Rain
10. Sayonara wo Oshiete
09. Sense Off – a Sacred tree
08. Ayakashibito
07. Himawari
06. Baldr sky dive 1
05. Saihate no Ima
04. Cross Channel
03. MOshimo Ashita ga Hare Naraba
02. Sharin no Kuni, Himawari no Shoujo
01. G senjyou no Maou
PS:
Sorry, but I only type in what I needed for searching in Vndb, I do really like his ranking because I saw what I wanted to see. A bit shame that some like Yume Miru, Crescendo,Remember 11… were not here. Ever17, I liked it but, yeah, not as much as CChannel (hopefully it’s can be higher).
As it’s quite scary that his Japanese is so good (like, how, Saihate no Ima some parts didn’t make sense to me so … hiatus).
For the small letter like (M) or (making) plz don’t worry about it since I forgot what it actually mean (maybe M= music, so that mean I liked its Music???? )
Remember11 isn’t an eroge, and I didn’t think Crescendo and R11 was that good either. I liked Yume Miru Kusuri too, but only Nekoko though~
Also, did you mean to cut off the titles? Quite few of the games had half its name cut off.
Well, there’s a bunch of other non-eroge titles in the list, including Clannad, Ever17 and Bye. The videos themselves specifically use the (often debated) term ‘Visual novel’ rather than ‘Eroge’ specifically so I could include these.
Note that the list would actually be quite a bit different now; 2009 added a heap of titles to it and I also feel differently about some of existing titles. Not really planning on recreating the video until the next wave of good things are released, which may not be until sometime in 2011.
@Asceai: Just a little note on your list:
= Part 1, I can’t find any game that named Serina that produced by Atelier Kaguya, I really like that Piano piece song, can you please provide the corrected name for it?
@Asceai #2: How your list changed, I really hope to have some glances of it (maybe in encubed? I just love to see new stuffs you have read and what you think about it :D)
@Choux: Well yeah, I typed as m watching the video without stopping, so basically the should be some typos and missing (but I think I putted enough pieces to search for it, really sorry for that.)
Thanks a lot, my internet is too slow to watch the videos.
I’m actually a little dissapointed by the rank Saya No Uta got, i mean, it left me feeling horrible with the absolute lack of a “good” ending, but i found it really interesting and well written
@blackhung
Corrected name? It’s called ‘Serina’. That’s the name of the game. It has no other name. There is nothing else you can call it!
http://www.a-kaguya.com/products_HB/serina/index.html (NSFW of course)
Well, things like Mugen Kairou 2, Shinigami no Seppun, Hoshizora no Memoria, Kitto、Sumiwataru Asairo yori mo, Full Metal Daemon Muramasa, Maji de Watashi ni Koi Shinasai, Natsuyume Nagisa and lots of other things I’ve somehow forgotten that have been released since I made the list would be on it now, other non-new titles that were out before but I hadn’t played at the time and turned out to be pretty good (Sekai no Subete, Te no Hira wo、Taiyouni and others), titles would be pushed out of the top 100 due to no longer fitting (bye bye, Kanon, for example), some things like Kimi ga Nozomu Eien are higher up on the list because I put them far too low down the first time without realising, things like CARNIVAL that I’d completely forgotten about when making the original list… etc. etc. you get the picture. I’d have to actually do work to make the list again and there’s a bunch of things coming out in March so…
Hi guys, can anyone help me?
I’m looking for one hentai/ero/dating sim game. You run around the island or maybe its city with character – you can control him, see him from above, not very detailed but nice.
You can have a variety of jobs that level up I think. Days are counting and I think somethink will happen when certain amount of days pass – horrible storm or wawe or something.
There is a lot of girls you can have relation with – one girl will day but if you made plot with her her ghost will be in your room. One girl is robot. There is some teacher/maybe teacher, not sure/ that gets drunk every now and then. If you have special book something happens in library. There is cemetery, park and lot of places where you can go. Restaurant. Thats all I recall.
ok im starting to think that most eroge makers hate women or are emotionaly unstable when it comes to women. because seriously.. I realy loathe those sadistic games n tentecles n eww o_o i know every1 has their vice but my god. mutilations.
But im glad i was able to pick out the good ones within your review. thankyou very much. this is really great help considering iv just started playin visual novels n_n
hello, im new to visual novels and I dont speak japanese so i was wondering if anyone could tell me which of these titles has been translated into english? thank you ^^
Glad to see both G-Senjou and Sharin no Kuni is in top 2, those are very epic and great VNs indeed.
wooo…do you mean erogames?anyone can list 200 best erogames?
can you please tell me were i can faind these visual novels in english for download??? thx
yume miru rocks
Aww… I really liked Ever17, though.
No Chaos;HEad or Steins:Gate?! BLASPHAMY!!!……..but then I noticed the list was made before they were released….all is forgiven. =D
I wonder how Katawa Shoujo would place if the list had been made this year.
Top 10! You bet your ass! Or your heart! Or your missing limbs!! Great characters, well planned and orchestrated story, fukkwin – GENIUS!
I saw your comments and had to check it out. Awesome! I’m so absorbed into it right now. Good call 🙂
I am sorry to ask this, considering it is probably obvious, But WHAT VN IS THAT IN his Banner?
The first is definetly “Devil on the G-string”.